How to Substitute or Replace Items on an Order

Last updated: October 21, 2026

You can swap one product for another on an order directly in your ShipHero portal at shipsfor.us, as long as the order has not been picked yet. Once an order has been picked, it can’t be edited. A substitution is two changes: you add the replacement item, then set the original item’s quantity to ship to zero.

You can also make the change in Shopify, and it syncs to ShipHero.

Before you start: The replacement item must have stock available, or the order will backorder and won’t ship. The search window in step 3 shows how many units are available for each SKU.

Steps

  1. Open the order. Log in to shipsfor.us, click Orders in the left-hand menu, search for the order and click the order number.

  2. Click Add items. In the Items section, click Add items.

  3. Add the replacement. Search for the replacement item by name, SKU or barcode. Check the box next to it, then click the blue Add Items button. It’s added with a quantity of one. To ship more, click its number in the Quantity to ship column, type the new number and click outside the field.

  4. Remove the original item. Click the number in the Quantity to ship column for the original item, type 0, then click anywhere outside the field. There’s no save button. A green confirmation message appears at the top of the page.

Verify

The replacement should show the correct quantity to ship, and the original should show 0. The original item stays listed on the order, but it won’t ship.

Warning: a substitution can change the order total in ShipHero, but not in your store. Adding the replacement increases the order total, and setting the original to 0 doesn’t reduce it. Handle any price difference or refund in your store or sales channel.

If the order isn’t ready to ship after the change, check the reason shown at the top of the order. If the order has already been picked, or you need help, contact your Account Manager.